The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Vol 91, 674-683, Copyright © 1986 by The American Association for Thoracic Surgery and The Western Thoracic Surgical Association
Bronchogenic carcinoma associated with upper aerodigestive cancers
A Yellin, LR Hill and JR Benfield
Of 1,450 patients with upper airway cancers, 189 (13%) had additional
cancers. There were 60 cases in which lung cancer occurred after upper
airway cancer and a single case in which it preceded upper airway cancer.
The occurrence of upper airway plus lung cancer in 61 patients was referred
to as multiple airway cancers. The overall incidence of multiple airway
cancers was 4.1%, or 1:112 patient-years at risk. The highest incidence of
lung cancer was 1:70 patient-years, and this was associated with laryngeal
cancer. The mean diagnostic interval between upper airway and lung cancers
was 6.1 (0 to 23) years, including nine cases (14.8%) in which the two were
synchronous. Triple endoscopy revealed occult lung cancer only once. The
use of mediastinoscopy (n = 9) and other surgical staging procedures (n =
9) was limited, because previous treatment of upper airway cancers made
such procedures impractical and also because interpretation of findings
would have been difficult. Past reports have indicated that lung cancer in
association with upper airway cancer is almost invariably squamous cell and
almost always develops in men. By contrast, among our 61 patients, the
incidence of adenocarcinomas was 24%, and 16 patients or 26% were women.
Among patients whose records could be evaluated in this regard, symptoms
were present in 27 of 55 (49%); the cancers were in Stage III at
presentation in 51%. Outcome was related to symptomatology and to lung
cancer stage. The median survivals for symptomatic and asymptomatic
patients were 6 and 25 months, respectively (p less than 0.001); the median
survivals for patients with Stage I, II, and III lesions were 26, 9, and 6
months, respectively (p less than 0.05). Post- thoracotomy management after
surgical-radiation therapy of upper airway cancers (n = 22) was
inordinately challenging because of preexisting impairment of the upper
airways. We have reached the following conclusions: Patients with upper
airway cancer are at high risk for lung cancer of all cell types. When
multiple airway cancers occur together, the prognosis is poor; nonetheless,
cure of each cancer can be achieved if it is completely and adequately
treated. When multiple airway cancers occur synchronously, the more
life-threatening cancer should be treated first. When the option exists,
the lung cancer should be treated before the upper airway cancer to avoid
the impact of previous irradiation and/or surgical treatment of the upper
airway cancer upon post-thoracotomy management.