The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Vol 92, 676-683, Copyright © 1986 by The American Association for Thoracic Surgery and The Western Thoracic Surgical Association
Resection of thoracic and abdominal teratoma in patients after cisplatin-based chemotherapy for germ cell tumor. Late results
PJ Loehrer, I Mandelbaum, S Hui, S Clark, LH Einhorn, SD Williams and JP Donohue
Fifty-one patients with primary testicular (N = 46) or mediastinal germ
cell cancer (N = 5) were treated from April, 1975, through May, 1981, and
had teratoma resected from residual disease after cisplatin-based
combination chemotherapy. All patients had normal serum markers before
resection of pulmonary (N = 12), mediastinal (N = 5), thoracoabdominal (N =
8), supraclavicular (N = 1) or abdominal disease (N = 25). Teratoma was
classified as mature teratoma (N = 29), immature teratoma (N = 15), or
immature teratoma with non-germ cell elements (N = 7). Thirty of 51 (60%)
patients remain free of recurrent disease, whereas 20 patients have either
recurrent carcinoma (N = 10) or teratoma (N = 10). One patient has a
presumed second malignancy. After additional chemotherapy, four patients
with recurrent carcinoma are alive and disease free and six have died.
After an additional operation, eight of 10 patients with recurrent teratoma
are long-term survivors. In four patients the initial relapse of carcinoma
developed more than 2 years after therapy; in an additional patient
carcinoma recurred after a 32 month disease-free survival period.
Univariate factors predicting for relapse include tumor burden, immature
teratoma with non-germ cell elements, and site (mediastinum), whereas only
immature teratoma with non-germ cell elements and site predicted for
survival. Immature teratoma and mature teratoma had similar relapse-free
intervals and overall survival intervals. According to a multivariate
analysis, primary tumor site at the mediastinum is the most significant
adverse factor predictive for both relapse and survival (two of five
patients survived). This study appears to support the various preclinical
models that demonstrate multipotential capabilities of teratoma. Complete
surgical excision of teratoma remains the most effective treatment with
continued close follow-up recommended for high-risk patients (immature
teratoma with non-germ cell elements, large tumor burden, or primary
mediastinal tumors.